Doom 3 vs. Half Life 2

[Heavygain]

Doom 3 for me.

[Biohazzard56]

Doom 3.

[Hezzy]

Neither work on my computer, so I'm going to have to say that they both suck.

EDIT: HOLY SHIT I AGREED WITH LIGHTFIRE!! PLEASE LET ME CHANGE MY VOTE!!!

[EineBeBoP]

Doom 3 = lose.

[UncleDynamite]

I'm a Half Life fan myself, so hence...

[Sputty]

Doom III, because I've been waiting 10 years for a new DOOM game

[Mag-Mower]

HL2... i dont know why... but i have a problem with id software... and doom, dont ask why, i dont know

[JetRaiden]

in terms of Single player HL2 will inch out over Doom 3, but HL2 will blow Doom 3 away in the long run.

[Dharkbayne]

I NEED TO GO BACK TO FRANCE

.

[Corrosion]

HL2

But I still love Doom3.

[Angel_of_Death]

Halo 2!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ya, fuck the PC. I'll rape you guys on consoles :D

[Setari]

where the FUCK is Halo 2 anywhere in this poll or thread for that matter :doh:


I'll probably get HL2 because of the mods. :rolleyes:

[r3d]

Pre-ordered:
Doom 3
Half-Life 2
Halo 2

[JetRaiden]

Halo 2!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ya, fuck the PC. I'll rape you guys on consoles :D

BLASPHEMY!

in all honesty, HL2 WILL be better then Halo 2.

[Hamma]

I doubt either will run, and my life priorities arent really in an order right now that fits in upgrading the computer.

[Biohazzard56]

I doubt either will run, and my life priorities arent really in an order right now that fits in upgrading the computer.

Developers dont develop games for $3,000 dollar computers they develop them for as many people as possible. Unless your running a Pentium 2 300mhz, your going to be fine. :doh:

[EarlyDawn]

in all honesty, HL2 WILL be better then Halo 2. :lol: :rofl:

[OneManArmy]

Half-Life 2 baby.

[JetRaiden]

:lol: :rofl:

come on, people will be using/playing HL2 long after Halo 2 starts to fall. come on, the difference from Halo to Halo 2 is not nearly as significant as Half Life to Half Life 2.

[Jennyboo]

Doom 3 - But I'll probably shit my pants from fear :lol:

[Hamma]

Time to get some extension cords so she can play from the toilet.

[Mag-Mower]

come on, people will be using/playing HL2 long after Halo 2 starts to fall. come on, the difference from Halo to Halo 2 is not nearly as significant as Half Life to Half Life 2.
yes, i figure a pc game can have a 8 year life span... and in 8 years in the console world, there will be 2 new systems in that span... so yes, HL2 wont make a big bang, like halo 2, but halo 2 will fizzle out in 2-3 years, hl2 will be arround for atleats 5 years

[Setari]

Time to get some extension cords so she can play from the toilet.
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:

[EarlyDawn]

come on, people will be using/playing HL2 long after Halo 2 starts to fall. come on, the difference from Halo to Halo 2 is not nearly as significant as Half Life to Half Life 2.Apples and Oranges. Half-Life 2 obviously wins that contest because it's neigh impossible to mod an X-Box game. We're talking about the initial quality. Otherwise it's an uneven comparison. ;)

[JetRaiden]

Apples and Oranges. Half-Life 2 obviously wins that contest because it's neigh impossible to mod an X-Box game. We're talking about the initial quality. Otherwise it's an uneven comparison. ;)

Halo 2 will dominate the console world, but HL2 will reign surpreme overall.

[EarlyDawn]

Halo 2 will dominate the console world, but HL2 will reign surpreme overall.Another no shit answer, I mean, I was thinking Halo 2 was gonna PWN on PC. :rofl:

[Indecisive]

Doom 3 - But I'll probably shit my pants from fear :lol:


You should try F.E.A.R :p

[Heavygain]

The more i think about it Half Life 2 is gonna be what i want, I wont buy it till the DoD source releases though.

[Everay]

cant decide, if Half Life 2 lives up to part one, and Doom 3 lives up to Doom 2, Doom3 wins, however, i forsee more of these new kid gamers, whom never even played the original doom or wolfenstien for that matter will pick HL2 because of the name.

but it is also important to note that these are almost two different generas, sure, both are FPS, but Doom3 is a horror game, and HL2 isnt, to my knowlege that is. Doom3 wins graphicaly too i think.

[martyr]

hl2.

doom came out on my little sister's fifth birthday, and i've played them all, i still have my floppycopy of ultimate doom (but no floppy drives).

half-life, however, was better, imo.

we'll see.

[Heavygain]

ive never beat half life, got too bored too fast in one player :(
Never played doom 2, beat doom 1.

[Everay]

Martyr, they do have a CD copy of all the Dooms for 10 bucks. wolfenstien 3d and Hexen on it too i think.

[Lonehunter]

Pre-ordered:
Doom 3
Half-Life 2
Halo 2
Amen

I thought HL2 would win :D

[Zatrais]

HL2 by miles, least its models don't look like they were made in plastic and different shades of grey and bown.

Only thing impressive to me in D3 is the lighting and shadows, rest look like crap.

Sides, anyone ever seen an open area in D3? Running in corridors went out with Quake 2 hehe.

[ViperGTS]

ive never beat half life, got too bored too fast in one player :(

:nod:
Martyr, they do have a CD copy of all the Dooms for 10 bucks. wolfenstien 3d and Hexen on it too i think.
It also come with a Doom 3 preview disk. Theres one level from wolfenstien on there...:(

[Heavygain]

As far as console world goes, the new conkers bad fir day is gonna own it all.
Fucking cats.

[TheN00b]

Half-Life 2 will probably be better, at least in some ways. From what I've seen, Doom 3 has the edge in cinematic effects by far, and in sound by a good bit. The games really reflect their creators' ideologies: id has always placed more emphasis on incredibly stunning (not immersive) graphics and ideas, while Vivendi and Valve place more of an emphasis on story and beauty, hence the lovely character modeling of Half-Life 2. Also, it appears that Half-Life 2 has a much better physics engine, which is really good for immersive gameplay.