At point blank range, how do pistols stand up to the supressor in TTK?

Fenrys · 2004-01-20, 02:16 AM

It seems like the MagScat would kill faster while the others would kill significantly slower.

Don't get me wrong, they all have their uses.

But it seems like the supressor is a mere common pool pistol that occupies a rifle slot because of the built-in silencer. Even the AMP appears to outkill it in close quarters (although a longer lifespan could be granted by being invisable w/ the amp, biasing my pov).

Personaly, I'd like to see all pistols buffed to kill faster than a supressor at close range, simply because it would make for more interesting fights in spawn rooms.

Jaged · 2004-01-20, 02:33 AM

Cloakers can already pwn my sniper ass too quickly. Do they need to make it faster?

GreyFlcn · 2004-01-20, 02:42 AM

Repeater, Yes
MagScatter, Yes
Beamer, About 50-55% slower

SilverLord · 2004-01-20, 11:33 AM

I think he's talking about making the Suppresser better?

Veteran · 2004-01-20, 11:58 AM

Go into VR and check out the AMP. If you fire one shot at a time, you will notice that it is amazingly useful for sniping.

Seriously. Fire one shot at a time with the AMP and note how often that one shot lands in the exact middle of the COF. Yes, sometimes it will not, but 60% or more of the time it will be a sniping weapon.

Then, consider that the AMP does some pretty harsh damage.

AMP is the ownage weapon if you must rely on a pistol-slot weapon. Second perhaps is the Spiker.

If you're using the Suppressor as anything but a fall-back weapon, you're out of your element.

Queensidecastle · 2004-01-20, 12:03 PM

The suppressor is shite and needs to stay that way. Just like Standard armor, you spawn at a disadvantage and this is how it should be. I find that it is easier to use a supressor to kill someone camping your tubes than the pistols but mostly this is because of the tight CoF and is forgiving if you miss a few shots

Black · 2004-01-20, 12:08 PM

the AMP is a awsome pistol it owns when your a cloaker or sniper with agile armor on.

Firefly · 2004-01-20, 12:15 PM

The AMP's usefulness is the fact that you can dump a ton of ammo into a target.

The Repeater's usefulness is its accuracy at stand-off range (stand-off for stealther, thanks).

The Mag-Scatter's usefulness is the damage it does. It's slower but the fucker does some nasty damage in three rounds.

The Beamer? Man I wouldn't use that if it were the only weapon around- I'd rather use my knife.

The Supressor- I had a medic on my team who was amazing with it. He racked up impressive kills. Don't underestimate the Supressor. It's got good range, decent damage, and awesome accuracy. It is, however, a basic weapon and should be considered a last resort in close-quarters battle. If Stealthers could carry a Supressor that would be well-received among some cloakers.

And as far as the Spiker- if you place the AMP above the Spiker, you're either warped or you're a fool who can't use it. I'd use the Spiker if I felt like spending time in the caverns getting a ton of them from my locker. I prefer using the Magscatter pistol simply because that roar turns me on and I consider it my trademark. Second to that, I use the AMP because it's common pool and can kill someone a little faster than the Magscatter.

Black · 2004-01-20, 12:19 PM

Originally Posted by Firefly

The AMP's usefulness is the fact that you can dump a ton of ammo into a target.

The Repeater's usefulness is its accuracy at stand-off range (stand-off for stealther, thanks).

The Mag-Scatter's usefulness is the damage it does. It's slower but the fucker does some nasty damage in three rounds.

The Beamer? Man I wouldn't use that if it were the only weapon around- I'd rather use my knife.

The Supressor- I had a medic on my team who was amazing with it. He racked up impressive kills. Don't underestimate the Supressor. It's got good range, decent damage, and awesome accuracy. It is, however, a basic weapon and should be considered a last resort in close-quarters battle. If Stealthers could carry a Supressor that would be well-received among some cloakers.

And as far as the Spiker- if you place the AMP above the Spiker, you're either warped or you're a fool who can't use it. I'd use the Spiker if I felt like spending time in the caverns getting a ton of them from my locker. I prefer using the Magscatter pistol simply because that roar turns me on and I consider it my trademark. Second to that, I use the AMP because it's common pool and can kill someone a little faster than the Magscatter.

Exactly u put all those points right on the dot

Fenrys · 2004-01-20, 02:32 PM

Seems like th supressor IS an AMP with a silencer on it. I'm not on a Buff the Supressor campaign. I'd like to see the empire pistols be more effective than the supressor in close quarters, but not at longer ranges.

Gunslanger · 2004-01-20, 02:35 PM

you know what a tek 9 is? what bullets does it take? 9mm. ok, you know what an MP5 is? what bullets does it take? 9mm. which one you think does more damage at close range? a pistol-i don't care how close range-should not do more damage than a rifle. the AMP is closer to a tek due to it being fully automatic, but still should not be more powerful than a rifle.

GreyFlcn · 2004-01-20, 08:38 PM

Actually Your going to find a lot of VS using the Supressor after this patch....
http://www.planetsideimages.com/uploads/killspeed.gif

Firefly · 2004-01-20, 08:56 PM

It might help if the two axis on that graph were labeled. Then the drunk folks would know what we're looking at.

They, I mean.

GreyFlcn · 2004-01-20, 09:00 PM

Kill Speed (Seconds) over Range

Notice past 40m range, you'd much rather be carrying a Suppresor.

dscytherulez · 2004-01-20, 08:37 PM

Eh...who the hell even relates things 2 tek-9's anymore? You should use something better well known (Uzi, Mac 10/11). Anyway, the reason an MP5 will be better than a pistol at close range is its firing speed and also the speed at which the bullet travels. The bullet of an MP5 will reach its target faster than an average pistol. You can also lay down on the trigger instead of pulling it repeatedly.

In all reality a well placed Desert Eagle shot will down someone much faster than some idiot who doesn't know what hes doing with an MP5. It really all depends on the user and their accuracy and reaction time.

But...Seeing as how this is a game, there is no judge of someones true handling of a gun, so they make the supressor a better weapon than a pistol...which, I think, is how it should be.