A weak point

windlord · 2012-06-19, 10:23 PM

I'm a graphic designer/Artist of 20 years.

Now I know that this is a subjective call. Furthermore I realise that for this next phase of Planetside this isn't going to change. Mostly due to the logistics.

However an opinion is just that.

I think that the guys really should have looked at the faction logos. I think the NC one is Ok however the other two really are poor. I would expect something like that from a first year arts student.

Considering just how pivotal these designs are to the rest of the game I would've thought that these designs really could have been reworked and improved to reflect the awesome qualities that the rest of the game exhibits.

Just my 2 cents.

AvacadoEight · 2012-06-19, 10:26 PM

Im okay with them. Don't necessarily think there's anything wrong with them. But that's just my opinion.

Baron · 2012-06-19, 10:26 PM

Excuse me sir ...

but I have been an internet troll for over 20 years

wait a sec, I need to call Al Gore and ask how old is the internets

The Kush · 2012-06-19, 10:27 PM

I think the logos are great but like you said everyone has an opinion.

Eyeklops · 2012-06-19, 10:27 PM

Are you blind? Obviously the VS emblem is the best looking and the TR & NC are shit. Get it right. T-ray come in here and set this man straight.

AvacadoEight · 2012-06-19, 10:30 PM

Originally Posted by Eyeklops

Are you blind? Obviously the VS emblem is the best looking and the TR & NC are shit. Get it right. T-ray come in here and set this man straight.

Ohhh no. At least our logo isn't a Y letter WANNABE!

( That was pathetic D: )

windlord · 2012-06-19, 10:59 PM

How would I fix them? Fair question.

Now I've been very gentle in my subjective educated opinion as I realise that everyone is an art director.

Ok firstly if you look at the NC logo you'll see the application of tone on the eagle device. Secondly you'll notice that the NC has two primary colours.

Obviously the composition of the main elements of the other two factions logos needs to be retained. However the basic stucture of the logos can be layered whereby an amount of detail can be added in, augmenting the detail to match that of the NC.

Then secondary and tertiary image enhancements could be added such as tone and texture. This would also allow secondary colours to be added to the logos.

I would offer to do it but it is the head designer/Art directors call. I know what it's like to be in a busy studio and to hear an opinion at the end of a project. Irritating at best I know, exasperating at the least.

So I can deal with it as is. however it's certainly something worthy of consideration.

Zulthus · 2012-06-19, 11:00 PM

Originally Posted by windlord

How would I fix them? Fair question.

Now I've been very gentle in my subjective educated opinion as I realise that everyone is an art director.

Ok firstly if you look at the NC logo you'll see the application of tone on the eagle device. Secondly you'll notice that the NC has two primary colours.

Obviously the composition of the main elements of the other two factions logos needs to be retained. However the basic stucture of the logos can be layered whereby an amount of detail can be added in, augmenting the detail to match that of the NC.

Then secondary and tertiary image enhancements could be added such as tone and texture. This would also allow secondary colours to be added to the logos.

I would offer to do it but it is the head designer/Art directors call. I know what it's like to be in a busy studio and to hear an opinion at the end of a project. Irritating at best I know, exasperating at the least.

So I can deal with it as is. however it's certainly something worthy of consideration.

You should post some examples of what you'd like to see improved in the logos.

windlord · 2012-06-19, 11:06 PM

Lol if I were a single man I'd offer to rework it.

Besides I don't really do graphics for free.

And furthermore any moderately experienced designer should know what to do.

It's a relatively simple brief and execution, which is why I'm surprised it wasn't really done.

Lastly I understand everyones position and I respect that. I'm just offering my opinion. Cheers.

Zulthus · 2012-06-19, 10:31 PM

Really? Seriously? For real? Honestly?

That's like saying the U.S Flag is really boring and unimaginative, and that it doesn't reflect how great we are. After all, I could make it in 1 minute on Paint.

Graywolves · 2012-06-19, 10:32 PM

I love the TR symbol, I've even considered having it tattooed on my person.

Nemises · 2012-06-20, 02:58 AM

Originally Posted by Graywolves

I love the TR symbol, I've even considered having it tattooed on my person.

You have a Person?...sweet!

Captain1nsaneo · 2012-06-20, 03:00 AM

Originally Posted by Graywolves

I love the TR symbol, I've even considered having it tattooed on my person.

Not mine.

GreatMazinkaise · 2012-06-19, 10:35 PM

Originally Posted by Zulthus

Really? Seriously? For real? Honestly?

That's like saying the U.S Flag is really boring and unimaginative, and that it doesn't reflect how great we are. After all, I could make it in 1 minute on Paint.

It is boring and unimaginative... but it's associated with 200+ years of great deeds, unspeakable horrors, and everything in between. You don't fuck with history.

Zulthus · 2012-06-19, 10:36 PM

Originally Posted by GreatMazinkaise

It is boring and unimaginative... but it's associated with 200+ years of great deeds, unspeakable horrors, and everything in between. You don't fuck with history.

Well that was pretty much my point. History and sentimental value.