What Happened To The Bases...

T MAN · 2012-07-11, 02:38 AM

I remember seeing this a long time ago and thought it looked great. A better improved PS1 base with buildings inside, etc. Now what im seeing is not like that at all, they gotten rid of the walls and sheilds and just better placement of things imo. Now looks more like team deathmatch as people here have been mentioning.

Maybe, im hopeing is that we have not heard all the infomation about upgrading bases, that would call from space and help fortify your base.
I remember Smedley pointing out the landing feet on that building in the first reveal.

Well see with coming soon beta i guess, can't wait.

Notser · 2012-07-11, 02:39 AM

I believe there are different types with walls and without, also could be that they want it to be a more combined arms battle within the bases.

fod · 2012-07-11, 02:42 AM

i noticed this also but i just guessed (hoped) it was a different type of base or something

i dont mind some open style base
i dont mind some closed in style bases (like the one in the first picture)
i DONT want ALL of them open or closed in - give us variety

Bags · 2012-07-11, 03:09 AM

If you look at the hi-rez map of indar, there's 2 bases that are 80% surrounded by walls.

The others are between 0% walls and 30% walled in.

Sturmhardt · 2012-07-11, 03:12 AM

Originally Posted by fod

i noticed this also but i just guessed (hoped) it was a different type of base or something

i dont mind some open style base
i dont mind some closed in style bases (like the one in the first picture)
i DONT want ALL of them open or closed in - give us variety

I second that.

Otleaz · 2012-07-11, 03:20 AM

I disagree. The more walled bases the better. You can find deathmatch areas at the lower tiered facilities.

Shadowrath · 2012-07-11, 05:37 AM

Originally Posted by Otleaz

I disagree. The more walled bases the better. You can find deathmatch areas at the lower tiered facilities.

More walled the better.

Xyntech · 2012-07-11, 03:22 AM

While we haven't seen much of the whole base wall thing in recent footage, we also haven't heard anything on the subject other than that some bases will be walled in and some won't be. That may have changed, but there isn't sufficient reason to believe so at the moment.

Also remember that base layouts are very modular this time around. They can easily add, subtract, and move around walls at will. This means several things.

For one thing, no two bases need be too similar. While there are only 3 major types of large base structure, they will each be surrounded by a unique layout of smaller structures.

It also means we will be able to have odd layouts where the geography is incorporated into the base layout, creating defensive locations totally unlike anything in the first Planetside.

And finally, the ease of modifying base layouts means that if the open bases end up being horrible fights where defenders just get hopelessly steamrolled all the time, they can easily add some walls back in.

Russ · 2012-07-11, 03:27 AM

Having all the basses the same creates more a static gameplay. assaulting every base is no different than the other. So by changing it up it allows offence to have an edge or defense, maybe even neither. It keeps gameplay varied enough so it doesn't seem repetitive and adds a uniqueness to each base. Not to mention giving tactical differences for both defense and offence to adapt and change to

I like them all being different. Down to every last boulder and shrub. And the developers are showing this as well.

Zidane · 2012-07-11, 03:50 AM

Originally Posted by Russ

Having all the basses the same creates more a static gameplay. assaulting every base is no different than the other. So by changing it up it allows offence to have an edge or defense, maybe even neither. It keeps gameplay varied enough so it doesn't seem repetitive and adds a uniqueness to each base. Not to mention giving tactical differences for both defense and offence to adapt and change to

I like them all being different. Down to every last boulder and shrub. And the developers are showing this as well.

I agree, by making all the bases different it will always allow for different types of assaults and defenses.

Otleaz · 2012-07-11, 04:02 AM

Originally Posted by Zidane

I agree, by making all the bases different it will always allow for different types of assaults and defenses.

There are plenty of ways to change a base without removing walls, though.

ringring · 2012-07-11, 05:35 AM

Originally Posted by Zidane

I agree, by making all the bases different it will always allow for different types of assaults and defenses.

True, but the downside is that you will be lost for longer and have more layouts to learn.

I give you caves - lots of people didn't like them because they couldn't find their way around
Even in current bases, how often have you been asked "Bio Lab, that's the one with the CC on the roof, right?'

**just pointing out an upside has a downside hiding somewhere**

Personally, I like the variety. I am not sure about the lack of walls but whether that is good or not I'll only come a solid opinion once I've been in game a seen and fought over it.

fvdham · 2012-07-11, 04:05 AM

Of course walls don't have to be attached to bases, they could make a Hadrian's wall across the map.

Raymac · 2012-07-11, 04:06 AM

You've got to be kidding me. Having a walled in area would be WAY more of a "deathmatch" arena than the layout Zurvan, for example, has now. You honestly think being surrounded by walls would make the game feel bigger??

Also, look at the terrain around that base. The hills and the buildings essentially create barriers and bottlenecks, but they do so in a much more organic way than freaking walls. I think it is brilliant design to be able to basically "hide" barriers.

Otleaz · 2012-07-11, 04:25 AM

Originally Posted by Raymac

You've got to be kidding me. Having a walled in area would be WAY more of a "deathmatch" arena than the layout Zurvan, for example, has now. You honestly think being surrounded by walls would make the game feel bigger??

Also, look at the terrain around that base. The hills and the buildings essentially create barriers and bottlenecks, but they do so in a much more organic way than freaking walls. I think it is brilliant design to be able to basically "hide" barriers.

I don't think you understand what walled combat is. It doesn't just delay some inevitable deathmatch, it completely changes the pace of the battle.