Anything Wrong with a Geforce?

SecondRaven · 2003-09-07, 06:09 PM

Well it seems to be everyone is saying Get a Radion 9800Pro and dont get a radion9800 non pro.....This is all fine but is their anything wrong with the GeforceFX5900 (256mb). I have a small delma, the computer dealer that I am buying from will only put a Radion9800 non pro which is a 128mb or a GeforceFX5900 which is a 256. I know that most of you are Radion Fans but help me out here. Tell me any info that you can on why i should get a GeforceFX5900 or why not.

OneManArmy · 2003-09-07, 07:32 PM

bottom line. I have a radeon, have had radeon ever since my old GF3... but the fx5900 is da shitl. just look at any review... nvidia has finally gotten thier heads out of thier asses... infact with my next paycheck i plan on picking one up.

but dont get the 256mb one its not worth all the extra money. hell quite honestly its not even worth and extra 20 bucks.... it doesnt benefit the average or even hardcore gamer in anyway....

SecondRaven · 2003-09-07, 07:54 PM

The 256 one is the only one that they offer in the package...

Kuraltai · 2003-09-07, 08:29 PM

I'm a loyal nVidia user .. have been for many years. While the thought of a Radeon is tempting, between the two choices you have, go with the GeForce .. you won't be disappointed.

Just upgraded from a TI-4200 and the FX5900 is killer .. I have the 128mb version though. Enjoy!

SecondRaven · 2003-09-07, 08:35 PM

So with your FX5900 128mb what do you get for FPS...also what are you sys specs Kuraltai

User58 · 2003-09-09, 10:22 PM

FX5900 was NVidia's answer to the 9700 Pro if I'm not mistaken, right?

:-)

OneManArmy · 2003-09-09, 11:28 PM

no the 5900 was just the next step, to beat the 9800 i guess, and it does!

Daleon · 2003-09-10, 03:07 PM

The 5900 does not "beat" the 9800 Pro. I'm not saying the 9800 Pro beats the 5900 either. Both cards are the best out right now, have excellent drivers, and can out perform the other depending on platform and benchmark cheats (I mean optimizations).

As far as planetside goes, its a toss up. As for games soon to come such as HL2 I think it will perform better on Ati. But Stalker is very likely to be better on NV. DM3 is going to be flakey and do 25 fps if your lucky on either.

I prefer the ATI camp b/c the product cycle is much more reliable. They meet their release dates. The r360 will be out before to long and NV will still be at the drawing board. The r400 will be out and ppl will be lucky if there is test silicon even ready for the next NV board.

But as far as your two choices, the 5900/256 is clearly better than a 9800 NP. So if performance is worth the money to you, get it ofcourse.

dscytherulez · 2003-09-11, 11:14 AM

I suggest you DO get the 256 because in the near future it will help, and then youll have it right away. If you dont, then youll almost have 2 upgrade to it sooner or later

PallarAndersVis · 2003-09-11, 01:05 PM

the radeon 9800 non pro is alot cheaper than either card, and it can be OCed to practically match them. the 5900 ultra and the 9800 pro however are about on par with eachother. they are both awesome top of the line cards right now and you cant go wrong with either one.

i went with the 9800 non pro though, its only 250 bucks, and I have OCed it to speeds even faster than the 9800 pro

Zakaah · 2003-09-11, 01:38 PM

Nothingis wrong with geforce i guess i went with it cos a 256mb 5600 (yes im not super rich and cannot afford monster cards) is way way way cheaper than the equivilent radeon and perfroms just as well with patched 3D-mark to get rid of optimaization plus mine came with a 3 games plus an ok demo disk

also it runs planetside beutifully now I have an athlon 2600 on an MSI nforce 2 board and MSI geforceFX 5600 256mb it runs brill with a bit of help fiddiling with things in planetside config

NoSurrender · 2003-09-11, 07:55 PM

daleon your right bout ATI pwnin in HL2 http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc.html?i=1862

User58 · 2003-09-11, 08:01 PM

I pulled the trigger on the 9800Pro. It will be here Monday.

Yoo Hoo!

EDIT: It's only the 128MB

OneManArmy · 2003-09-12, 01:38 AM

well after finding out about HL2 and nvidias shitty performance... yea fuck it... I'll be getting a 9800 pro (128mb version of course, if you cough up that much dough for a 256 one your fucking stupid and dont even deserve a god damned computer)

NoSurrender · 2003-09-13, 02:26 AM

Yay! go OMA... OMA WE HAFTA PLAY SOMETHING!!! U ME AND AGENT!!!