Think Feudal Japan

[duomaxwl]

The base being taken DOES mean something. It means your capturing territory, and getting resources. We don't need inter-empire ass kicking going on. I'm not being an elitist. I said if you want politics, go play Eve. I'm not saying don't play Planetside 2. It's just what you are wanting is not what the game is made for.

[Talek Krell]

Originally Posted by FatCandy

What a wretched community if you don't blindly love PS2 you get eaten alive, I'm not sorry for pointing out this games week area and trying to start a discussion about how to fix it. F you guys

The fact that you, specifically, without any form of statistical backing or even anecdotal evidence, think that something is a problem does not make it so.

This idea conflicts with fundamental aspects of the game and you have no one but yourself to blame for not having done the research to understand that.

And please don't feed Stew's threads, it only encourages him.

[Purple]

Originally Posted by FatCandy

when I came on these forums I was greeted by PC elitists and ignorance in an arbitrary thread pitting Dust 514 against PS2 I defended it there even though I had come to talk about PS2. I eventually posted this, because I thought at the least it would be interesting to some of you, but instead got you guys saying no...just no and saying it was a bad idea. you guys are assholes and I mean it blind, ignorant, and annoying assholes! What a wretched community if you don't blindly love PS2 you get eaten alive, I'm not sorry for pointing out this games week area and trying to start a discussion about how to fix it. F you guys

kind of a harsh response. you cant get attached to your ideas on this fourm. the reason we post these ideas is to see if it is right for the community. people saying they dont like the idea is not the same as saying they dont like you. the issue with your idea si it would just turn this game into a FFA. if that would happen then they would have to turn off their anti grief system and that would open a large can of worms. also new players wouldn't have a clue as to what is going on and hence stop playing. the game depends on lots of players joining and this would drive people away.

[Rexdezi]

Originally Posted by FatCandy

when I came on these forums I was greeted by PC elitists and ignorance in an arbitrary thread pitting Dust 514 against PS2 I defended it there even though I had come to talk about PS2. I eventually posted this, because I thought at the least it would be interesting to some of you, but instead got you guys saying no...just no and saying it was a bad idea. you guys are assholes and I mean it blind, ignorant, and annoying assholes! What a wretched community if you don't blindly love PS2 you get eaten alive, I'm not sorry for pointing out this games week area and trying to start a discussion about how to fix it. F you guys

PC Elitist? Did you really just call me that???? Dude, the ONLY games I play on PC so far is Minecraft, Mount and Blade: Warband and maybe 18 hours of Team Fortress 2... thats IT.

Just because your idea sucks balls, doesn't make us PC elitists or assholes, arrogant ignorant annoying or whatever the fuck else you want to call us.

The "weak area" that you have pointed out isn't a weak area at all. It's something YOU don't like about the game... but you know what? THATS FINE! I don't like that there are NS vehicles, I don't like that there are only 3 continents. But I'm not fucking arrogant enough to say that it's the games weak area. Its an area of the game that I think isn't perfect, but you know what? IM NOT PERFECT, MAYBE IM WRONG ABOUT THAT!

You call me arrogant? Fuck you! You're the arrogant one!

YOUR IDEA SUCKS! There, thats it. No if's but's or maybe's. Doesn't make me anything other than truthful.

[FatCandy]

Originally Posted by Talek Krell

The fact that you, specifically, without any form of statistical backing or even anecdotal evidence, think that something is a problem does not make it so.

This idea conflicts with fundamental aspects of the game and you have no one but yourself to blame for not having done the research to understand that.

And please don't feed Stew's threads, it only encourages him.

if you think that mindlessly capturing, losing, and recapturing bases is a fundamental of the game then *puts on sun glasses* there is something fundamentally wrong with the game! In all seriousness though I don't see why it's not subject to change. I just want taking a base to mean something the next day if I spend time planning an all out invasion of a base with my clan and it works I want it to matter for more than 24 hours. I have an incredibly hard time believing you don't want more depth.

As for my rage I was getting pissed at stew's thread, then I come to this thread and see people being dicks and just saying that it was stupid and a really bad idea in every way, I'm pretty sure that would set most people off as I expected stuff like I think that idea wouldn't really work in PS2, or here are some things I would change, because I can't really see that happening. I'm sorry for how it came off, but not about you guys being assholes as there really isn't any point in saying no... just no, especially in a thread about ideas I accept constructive criticism, but not just people saying that it sucks.

[Rexdezi]

Originally Posted by FatCandy

if you think that mindlessly capturing, losing, and recapturing bases is a fundamental of the game then *puts on sun glasses* there is something fundamentally wrong with the game!

If you think that there is something fundamentally wrong with what this game is all about, yet you are still excited enough about it to make an account and come on its forums... THEN THERE IS SOMETHING FUNDAMENTALLY WRONG WITH YOU!

On a lighter note; FUCK YEAH PROMOTED TO CORPORAL!

[FatCandy]

Originally Posted by Purple

kind of a harsh response. you cant get attached to your ideas on this fourm. the reason we post these ideas is to see if it is right for the community. people saying they dont like the idea is not the same as saying they dont like you. the issue with your idea si it would just turn this game into a FFA. if that would happen then they would have to turn off their anti grief system and that would open a large can of worms. also new players wouldn't have a clue as to what is going on and hence stop playing. the game depends on lots of players joining and this would drive people away.

it's not that people didn't like my idea I'm fine with that, but if you read how they stated they didn't like it it's pretty rude.

[Rexdezi]

Originally Posted by FatCandy

not just people saying that it sucks.

what if Yoda told you it sucks?

[FatCandy]

Originally Posted by Rexdezi

If you think that there is something fundamentally wrong with what this game is all about, yet you are still excited enough about it to make an account and come on its forums... THEN THERE IS SOMETHING FUNDAMENTALLY WRONG WITH YOU!

On a lighter note; FUCK YEAH PROMOTED TO CORPORAL!

this game can be good, it has the possibility, that's why I offered my advice. It also won't be bad just not amazing.

[Rexdezi]

Originally Posted by FatCandy

this game can be good, it has the possibility, that's why I offered my advice. It also won't be bad just not amazing.

This game will most likely good. It has amazing potential. If they followed your advice, the game would be a FPS version of Tribal Wars. It would be bad, it would not be amazing. It would ruin the game.

Idea's for improving the game... Not fundamentally changing the mechanics of the game. Stick to the small stuff

[FatCandy]

Originally Posted by Rexdezi

This game will most likely good. It has amazing potential. If they followed your advice, the game would be a FPS version of Tribal Wars. It would be bad, it would not be amazing. It would ruin the game.

Idea's for improving the game... Not fundamentally changing the mechanics of the game. Stick to the small stuff

you are saying that you are fine with the fact that winning a base currently means nothing, because in a week, even a day you prob won't still own the base.

[Elochai]

You keep citing Italy/Rome, and Japan, mentioning warring tribes and talking about it being not unified. Planetside 2 only has three unified factions. apparently there are two reasons to dissent from the TR. 1. you love robots(go to VS). 2. Everything else(go to NC).

It would be very hard for this game to have a Tribe/clan system working underneath the faction system. If the two were somehow to exist, I believe that fighting for your class/tribe would be more important than fighting for your faction, and it would take away from having three factions.

[duomaxwl]

Originally Posted by FatCandy

you are saying that you are fine with the fact that winning a base currently means nothing, because in a week, even a day you prob won't still own the base.

That's the point of the game! That's how it works!

[Goku]

This thread has run its course.