[Repost] Star Wars: EP III Trailer - Page 3

Lonehunter · 2004-11-05, 01:39 PM

Originally Posted by ChewyLSB

Like I said before, he didn't direct ESB or RoTJ. The directors of those two movies are DEAD, and he can't even consult them, so he has no right to change the movies.

Originally Posted by Hamma

he owns star wars so he can do with it what he wants

I Hate Pants · 2004-11-05, 02:18 PM

Who dat????

Sentrosi · 2004-11-05, 02:21 PM

Originally Posted by ChewyLSB

In case you haven't realized...
In case you haven't realized...

In case you didn't realize, Luke's mission during all of RoTJ was to convert Anakin back to the light side. So, basically, what George Lucas is now saying, is that Luke Skywalker utterly failed in his mission, as Anakin Skywalker appears in his younger, dark side form, rather than his form right before he died, when Luke converts him back to the light side.

Apparently I have not realized. However, I'm forced to go Darth Maul on that above post.

Failed? Nah, I don't see that at all. He brought back his Father. His father is Hayden Christiansen, face and all. Not Bernard Shaw. Replacing Bernard Shaw shows that Luke DID succeed in bringing his father back from the Dark Side.

But, apparently I do not realize, so I'll stop pandering to your unique Jediness.

EarlyDawn · 2004-11-05, 02:32 PM

I tend to agree with Chewy. FORCING you to watch it in the new form with no option to watch it as it was originally is rather... idiotic.

Sentrosi · 2004-11-05, 03:06 PM

Who is forcing anyone to go out and purchase the DVDs? Not me. Not George Lucas.

ChewyLSB · 2004-11-05, 07:04 PM

Originally Posted by Sentrosi

Apparently I have not realized. However, I'm forced to go Darth Maul on that above post.

Failed? Nah, I don't see that at all. He brought back his Father. His father is Hayden Christiansen, face and all. Not Bernard Shaw. Replacing Bernard Shaw shows that Luke DID succeed in bringing his father back from the Dark Side.

But, apparently I do not realize, so I'll stop pandering to your unique Jediness.

Yes, I do like the phrase "In case you haven't realized..." Sue me.

Actually, by showing Hayden Christensen, it shows that Luke utterly failed in his mission. A force ghost is, like I said before, only for light side jedi's, so by showing Hayden Christensen, it shows that Luke DIDN'T convert Vader back to the light side, as the ghost should take the form of the last time that Vader was light side. By showing Hayden Christensen, it shows that Luke didn't convert Anakin back to the light side, and makes it appear as though the last time he was a light side jedi was when he was young.

Hamma · 2004-11-05, 10:31 PM

You know.. movies lose their fun when people over analyze them

ChewyLSB · 2004-11-05, 10:49 PM

Originally Posted by Sentrosi

Who is forcing anyone to go out and purchase the DVDs? Not me. Not George Lucas.

Before this thread gets locked for derailing, I wanted to respond to this.

What about people who enjoy the originals more than the SE's? Like me, for example. Sure, I have more original VHS's, and that's great, but eventually, those VHS's are going to break, and then I'm just ****ed. There is absolutely no way to legally get the original's anymore.

Hamma · 2004-11-05, 10:58 PM

naw I wont lock it, it could be worse.

Infernus · 2004-11-05, 11:15 PM

Originally Posted by Hamma

You know.. movies lose their fun when people over analyze them

Yep...

Derfud · 2004-11-06, 12:02 AM

Chewy, anakin's ghost is in his younger form, yet before he was seduced by the dark side. As another one of the premiere starwars nerds in this forum I can also verify that lucas doesnt need to consult directors, hell, there is nothing ethically wrong with it. Why? He wrote starwars, he doesnt need any more permission. Also the whole Hayden Christensen thing makes sense when you think about it. The other guy who originally played anakin's ghost was never in any of the movies? He was only ever in that very last scene.

On a final note, I can also verify that this is indeed an ewok:

Corrosion · 2004-11-06, 12:09 AM

Originally Posted by ChewyLSB

I don't feel like pulling a Corrosion.

Is that a verb now?

I Hate Pants · 2004-11-06, 01:07 AM

Originally Posted by Derfud

On a final note, I can also verify that this is indeed an ewok:
http://cgi.theforce.net/theforce/ima...wok_teaser.jpg

are you shitting me?????? talk about wasting your life. I wonder if the guy watched the trailer frame by frame to stumble across that.

That really ruined the coolness of the trailer

Derfud · 2004-11-06, 01:16 AM

It may have just caught his eye when he first watched it, then went back and did it frame by frame.

Sputty · 2004-11-06, 02:12 AM

I don't see it